Fixed Deposit: File Complaint Against Helios & Matheson Information Technology

[ADMIN]

How Fixed Deposit Holders Can File a Complaint Against Helios and Matheson Information Technology in India

Fixed deposit (FD) holders in India who invested with Helios and Matheson Information Technology Ltd. (H&M) have faced significant challenges due to the company's failure to repay principal amounts and interest. This article provides a comprehensive, step-by-step guide for affected FD holders, particularly senior citizens and retail investors, on how to file complaints against H&M to seek redressal. Written in simple English, this guide aims to empower depositors with practical knowledge to navigate the legal and regulatory landscape in India.

---

Understanding the Helios and Matheson Case

Helios and Matheson Information Technology Ltd., once a prominent IT company based in Chennai, collected substantial funds through fixed deposits, promising attractive returns. Thousands of depositors, many of whom were senior citizens, invested their hard-earned money, lured by high interest rates. However, since mid-2014, the company stopped repaying depositors, citing financial difficulties and changes in the Companies Act, 2013. This led to widespread complaints, with many depositors reporting bounced cheques due to insufficient funds or payments stopped by the company.

The situation escalated with legal actions, including a liquidation order by the Madras High Court, investigations by the Economic Offences Wing (EOW), and probes by the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO). Despite these measures, many depositors are still awaiting recovery of their funds. Filing a complaint is a critical step toward seeking justice, and this guide outlines the process in detail.

---

Why File a Complaint?

Filing a complaint is essential for FD holders to:

- Seek Redressal: Registering a formal complaint with relevant authorities increases the chances of recovering your investment.
- Hold the Company Accountable: Complaints contribute to investigations that may uncover financial mismanagement or fraud.
- Join Collective Action: Many depositors have formed welfare associations to strengthen their case, and your complaint can support such efforts.
- Prevent Future Scams: Highlighting issues with H&M can push regulators to tighten oversight on corporate fixed deposits.

---

Step-by-Step Guide to Filing a Complaint

Below is a detailed roadmap for FD holders to file complaints against Helios and Matheson, tailored to India's legal and regulatory framework.

Step 1: Gather Essential Documents

Before filing a complaint, collect all relevant documents to substantiate your claim. These include:

- Fixed Deposit Receipt (FDR): The original or a copy of the FD receipt issued by H&M, which includes details like the deposit amount, maturity date, and interest rate.
- Cheques Issued by H&M: Copies of bounced cheques or post-dated cheques that were dishonored due to "insufficient funds" or "payment stopped by drawer."
- Correspondence Records: Any emails, letters, or SMS exchanges with H&M regarding repayment issues.
- Bank Statements: Statements showing attempts to deposit cheques and their subsequent rejection.
- Identity Proof: A government-issued ID (Aadhaar, PAN, or voter ID) to verify your identity.
- Proof of Investment: Receipts or transaction records showing the payment made to H&M for the FD.

Organize these documents in a folder, both physically and digitally, to streamline the complaint process.

Step 2: Contact Helios and Matheson Directly

Although H&M has been unresponsive in many cases, the first step is to formally communicate your grievance to the company. This establishes a record of your attempt to resolve the issue amicably.

- Write a Formal Letter: Draft a letter addressed to H&M's registered office at Ascendas International Tech Park, 4th Floor, Crest, Phase II, CSIR Road, Taramani, Chennai, Tamil Nadu 600113. Include:
  - Your name, address, and contact details.
  - FD details (reference number, deposit amount, maturity date).
  - Details of non-payment (e.g., bounced cheques).
  - A request for immediate repayment with interest.
  - A deadline (e.g., 15 days) for response, failing which you will escalate the matter.
- Send via Registered Post: Use registered post or courier to ensure delivery confirmation.
- Email Communication: If you have an official email address for H&M, send a copy of the letter digitally and request a read receipt.
- Keep Records: Retain copies of the letter, postal receipt, and any responses (or lack thereof).

Note that H&M's responses have been inconsistent, with many depositors reporting no reply. However, this step is crucial for legal documentation.

Step 3: File a Complaint with the Economic Offences Wing (EOW)

The EOW, a specialized police unit, investigates financial frauds and economic offenses. Since H&M's non-payment of FDs has led to multiple complaints under the Tamil Nadu Protection of Interests of Depositors (TNPID) Act, 1997, and Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code (cheating), the EOW is a key authority to approach.

- Locate the Nearest EOW Office: For depositors in Tamil Nadu, contact the EOW headquarters in Chennai. For those outside Tamil Nadu, approach the EOW division in your state's capital or major city.
- Prepare a Complaint Letter: Include:
  - Your personal details (name, address, contact).
  - FD details and evidence of non-payment (e.g., bounced cheques).
  - A reference to the TNPID Act and IPC Section 420.
  - A request for investigation and recovery of funds.
- Submit the Complaint: Visit the EOW office in person to submit your complaint or send it via registered post. Attach copies of all documents.
- Follow Up: Obtain an acknowledgment receipt or FIR copy (if registered) and periodically check the status of your complaint. You can also email or call the EOW for updates.

The EOW has previously arrested H&M's directors and frozen bank accounts, indicating their authority to act in such cases.

Step 4: Approach the Company Law Board (CLB) or National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT)

The CLB, now largely replaced by the NCLT, oversees corporate governance issues, including non-payment of fixed deposits under the Companies Act, 2013.

- File a Petition with NCLT: Since H&M is under liquidation, the NCLT Chennai bench is the appropriate forum. You can file a petition under Section 73 or 74 of the Companies Act, 2013, which governs repayment of deposits.
- Draft the Petition: Include:
  - Your details and FD specifics.
  - Evidence of non-payment.
  - A request for repayment or inclusion in the liquidation process.
- Engage a Lawyer: Given the complexity of NCLT proceedings, consider hiring a lawyer specializing in corporate law. If cost is a concern, seek legal aid through district legal services authorities.
- Submit the Petition: File the petition with the NCLT Chennai bench, either in person or through your lawyer. Pay the required filing fees (consult the NCLT website for details).
- Monitor Liquidation Proceedings: Since H&M is under liquidation, the official liquidator appointed by the Madras High Court is responsible for distributing assets to creditors, including FD holders. Ensure your claim is registered with the liquidator.

Step 5: File a Complaint with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA)

The MCA oversees corporate compliance and can forward complaints to the SFIO for investigation.

- Submit an Online Complaint: Visit the MCA's Investor Grievance Redressal portal and file a complaint. You'll need H&M's Corporate Identity Number (CIN), available on the MCA website.
- Details to Include:
  - Your personal and FD details.
  - Evidence of non-payment.
  - A request for SFIO investigation.
- Follow Up: After 30 days, file a Right to Information (RTI) application with the MCA to check the status of your complaint and any actions taken.

The MCA has previously referred H&M complaints to the SFIO, which is investigating the company for fraud and siphoning of funds.

Step 6: Lodge a Complaint with SEBI

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) regulates listed companies like H&M. Although SEBI's primary focus is securities, it can address investor grievances related to listed entities.

- Use the SCORES Platform: SEBI's SCORES (SEBI Complaints Redress System) allows online complaint filing.
- Steps to File:
  - Register on the SCORES portal.
  - Submit your complaint with details of your FD, non-payment evidence, and a request for action.
  - Attach scanned copies of documents.
- Track Progress: SCORES provides a tracking ID to monitor your complaint's status.

SEBI has previously fined H&M for financial irregularities, so your complaint may contribute to further scrutiny.

Step 7: Join or Form a Depositors' Welfare Association

Many H&M depositors have formed welfare associations to collectively pursue their claims. Joining or forming such a group can amplify your voice.

- Find Existing Groups: Search for H&M depositor groups on social media platforms or through consumer complaint forums.
- Form a Group: If no group exists in your area, connect with other depositors (avoid sharing personal details publicly) and form an association. Elect representatives to coordinate legal actions.
- Collective Action: Associations can file joint petitions with the NCLT, EOW, or MCA, increasing pressure on authorities. They can also pool resources to hire legal representation.

Step 8: File a Consumer Complaint

FD holders can approach consumer courts under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, as non-payment constitutes a deficiency in service.

- Locate the Consumer Forum: File at the district, state, or national consumer disputes redressal commission based on the claim amount:
  - District: Up to Rs. 50 lakh.
  - State: Rs. 50 lakh to Rs. 2 crore.
  - National: Above Rs. 2 crore.
- Prepare the Complaint: Include:
  - Your details and FD specifics.
  - Evidence of non-payment.
  - A claim for principal, interest, and compensation for mental harassment.
- File the Complaint: Submit the complaint with a nominal fee (varies by forum) and attend hearings, either personally or through a lawyer.

Consumer courts are relatively accessible and have helped depositors in similar cases recover funds.

Step 9: Explore Legal Action Under the Negotiable Instruments Act

If H&M issued cheques that bounced, you can file a case under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.

- Issue a Legal Notice: Within 30 days of the cheque bouncing, send a legal notice to H&M demanding payment within 15 days.
- File a Criminal Complaint: If H&M fails to pay, file a complaint in a magistrate court within one month of the notice period's expiry. Attach:
  - The bounced cheque.
  - Bank memo stating the reason for dishonor.
  - A copy of the legal notice and postal receipt.
- Engage a Lawyer: A lawyer can help navigate this process, as it involves court appearances.

Step 10: File an RTI Application

To track the progress of your complaints or gather information on H&M's liquidation, file RTI applications with relevant authorities (MCA, SEBI, EOW, NCLT).

- Draft the RTI: Request details like:
  - Actions taken on your complaint.
  - Status of H&M's liquidation.
  - SFIO investigation updates.
- Submit Online or Offline: Use the RTI online portal or send a physical application with a Rs. 10 fee.
- Follow Up: Authorities must respond within 30 days. Escalate to the appellate authority if responses are unsatisfactory.

---

Additional Tips for FD Holders

- Avoid Panic: Legal processes are slow, but persistence is key. Document every step and follow up regularly.
- Seek Legal Aid: If you're a senior citizen or financially strained, approach district legal services authorities for free legal assistance.
- Stay Informed: Monitor news and court updates on H&M's liquidation to know when funds may be disbursed.
- Beware of Scams: Avoid third-party agencies promising quick recovery for a fee, as they may exploit your situation.
- Diversify Investments: In the future, avoid unsecured corporate FDs. Opt for safer options like bank FDs or government-backed schemes.

---

Challenges You May Face

- Slow Legal System: India's judicial processes can be time-consuming, especially with H&M under liquidation.
- Limited Recovery: Liquidation may not yield full repayment if H&M's assets are insufficient.
- Unresponsive Authorities: Some agencies may act as "post offices," forwarding complaints without prompt action.
- Company's Tactics: H&M has been accused of delaying tactics in courts, which may prolong resolution.

Despite these challenges, collective action and persistent follow-up can improve outcomes.

---

Lessons from the Helios and Matheson Case

The H&M case highlights the risks of investing in corporate fixed deposits, especially with companies offering unusually high interest rates. Key takeaways include:

- Check Credit Ratings: Only invest in FDs from companies with AAA or AA ratings from agencies like CRISIL or ICRA.
- Research the Company: Investigate the company's financial health and track record before investing.
- Regulatory Oversight: Demand stronger regulations to protect FD holders from corporate defaults.
- Diversify Investments: Spread your investments across safer instruments to minimize risk.